After sanding an old pine window sill, I was able to stain it to closely match the surrounding pine trim, but the "sheen" doesn’t quite match. What can I do to add a VERY VERY slight semi gloss finish to it? Varnish would be way too shiny. Is there a clear oil or wax you can recommend? Or should I have used a different type of stain? Thx.
another thing to consider besides stain/wax/oil would be a sealer of some kind?